Friday, August 21, 2009

Loan Modification and Foreclosure Rates: The Plan's Not Working

Obviously the Obama Administration's plan to reduce foreclosure rates by encouraging loan modifications isn't working.

The foreclosure rate is still rising and is, in fact, at an all-time high short of the Great Depression.

And most participants and observers of the program (including me) consider it a failure.

Reprinted below from ABC News is an excellent piece on why the Obama loan modification program isn't going to work.

Of course it isn't. Common sense says this. How do you get people to stay owners of homes they obviously cannot afford? Or don't want anymore because they are underwater on the mortgage?

Modifying most mortgage loans is like doing emergency dental work on a death row inmate.

Nice gesture, some short term pain relief, but the futility of the effort is obvious.

Robert J. Abalos, Esq.

Foreclosure Frustration: The Trouble With Loan Modifications

Homeowners at Risk of Foreclosure Face Hurdles Even After Their Loan Modifications Begin


Aug. 21, 2009—

Six months after the government announced that the Making Home Affordable program would help stem the tide of foreclosures, the opposite appears to be happening.

The Making Home Affordable program was launched in February to help address the foreclosure crisis brought on by rising unemployment and tighter credit. At the time, the Treasury Department said that the program would help between 3 and 4 million homeowners. So far, fewer 10 percent have had their mortgages modified, and those who have tried have said that the process is slow and frustrating.

When 80-year-old Gloria Lowe applied this spring, she was out of work and on the brink of losing her home.

"My pay(check) took care of the extra bills, my mortgage and my equity loan. And when that stopped, there was no way for me to pay it," Lowe said.

Lowe said she tried calling her bank for help, but got nowhere, so she turned to the Consumer Credit Counseling Service of Delaware Valley. Credit counselors there helped Lowe submit the reams of paperwork needed to modify her first and second loan.

But four months later, she found out she was still at risk of foreclosure and would have to start all over again. Even though her bank modified the first mortgage, it never looked at reducing the rate on her second loan.

"People are going to loan servicers and they're not getting through. When they get through, the responses are incredibly slow. They provide paperwork time and again, and the paperwork gets lost. It's like banging your head against a wall," said Ira Rheingold, executive director of the National Association of Consumer Advocates.

"This program, as it's working today, is simply not making a dent in what needs to happen so that our economic recovery can continue," he said.

More Loan Modifications Soon?

The Treasury Department admits that the program got off to a slow start, but it also says that banks are adding more staff to handle calls and that more than 400,000 applications are currently pending.

There's good news for Gloria Lowe too. Her bank told ABC News that they've fast-tracked the loan modification application on her second mortgage.

That's not the norm, however, for the nation. The Treasury Department's advice for others like Gloria is to go to a non-profit credit counseling agency to get help dealing with their bank. Officials say that's a much faster way than navigating the system alone.